Skip to main content

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity, Ed Catmull

A reading which aided my learning greatly during the course of this module was an article written in 2008 by Ed Catmull, the president of Pixar. This reading was based on creativity and although written about Pixar, is applicable to all businesses and industries.
Prior to reading this paper, my beliefs were such that the creativity arises from individuals and not from those working in groups. This belief arose from my knowledge on the subject of “groupthink”, where team members make decisions based on consensus rather than selecting the best ideas.
Ed Catmull stresses however, that “creativity involves a large number of people from different disciplines working effectively together to solve a great many problems.” (Catmull, 2008) The author also underlines that it is more important to invest in good people rather than good ideas through explaining that, “creativity involves a large number of people from different disciplines working effectively together to solve a great many problems.” (Catmull, 2008)
This idea is highlighted in the IDEO video where we see individuals from a variety of backgrounds, including Psychology and Biology working together to solve complex problems, in an innovative and creative way. This concept is further emphasised in the Hargadon et al. paper where, the authors suggest that Thomas Edison should be seen as a collective noun as “Edison is in reality a collective noun and means the work of many men”. (Hargadon & Bechky, 2006)
Catmull also underlines it is more important to invest in good people rather than good ideas through explaining that “if you give a good idea to a mediocre team, they’ll screw it up. But if you give a mediocre idea to a great team, they’ll make it work.” (Catmull, 2008)

Pixar encourage their people to ask for help from their colleagues and to seek feedback so as to prevent failures. This is done through “dailies” and the company “creative brain trust”.  Like IDEO, the company accept and encourage failure and have post-mortems to discuss what went well and didn’t go well in each project.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Research Essay

A major assessment component for the Design, Development and Creativity module was conducting a research essay which involved working individually or in pairs. Myself and my partner, Beth conducted our research essay on updating a digital product, the UCD student portal through the introduction of a digital collaboration tool as a core offering for all students studying at the University. This essay involved conducting both primary and secondary research. In terms of primary research, we conducted a questionnaire, interviews and observational research to understand how students currently interact with the UCD student portal and how it can be improved. Once we understood the problems associated with blackboard and how it could be updated by making it a more engaging site, we conducted secondary research, studying existing literature and case studies on the topics of collaboration and utilising collaborative tools. Upon decision on the update required, a usability, requi...

Week 4 Lecture

Introduction During this lecture, we discussed different methods for software development including waterfall and Agile. Waterfall is a rigid way to approach software development. It can be beneficial to projects where there are little to no unknown factors as it is a rigid, structured and organized process Releasing iteratively is a useful way to approach software development projects when there is an element of uncertainty. It allows for feedback and changes throughout the development lifecycle.  Required Readings During the lecture, we reflected in small groups on the readings. A reading which stood out for me this week was the Brooks "No Silver Bullet" paper. I enjoyed the metaphor of the werewolf which was used to describe the complexities associated with SDLC which teams don't envision from the onset of the project. The paper stresses that investing in good developers is far more important than attempting to find a solution or a "silver bu...

Designing a Robot

In week 9, we worked in small groups to create a robot using an instruction manual and upon creating our robot, we were tasked with creating a "run" function so that our robot could drive around and "guard a base." (for the purpose of the class, the base was a large white box) This exercise was great fun, but at times stressful as we were required to create our robot within a short time constraint. To create our robot within the allotted time, my group divided the tasks amongst us. One individual called out the required materials needed and where they were to be placed, one found the necessary materials and two individuals put the robot together. As requested by our lecturer, we switched roles frequently so that each member got experience working on each of the tasks required. Dividing the roles out amongst ourselves enabled us to create our robot more quickly than if we had completed each of the tasks together as a group.